RE-Review

General Discussion Started Last reply 14 posts
MMORPG.com has done a re-review of Lineage2.

Some points will come out fast from this..
First, the community tab.. IMHO, so much understimated as we have a really nice community here.
Not so equal to those community like [censored] or blah, which are made for in-game drama and so on.. and seems the reviewer looked only at those communities, not considering that they are made for a certain purpouse.

The second part..


The downside to Customer Service is that, while our voices are being answered, they still aren’t being heard. Reporting a bot has very little effect; rarely do they actually disappear, not matter how many times you report them.



Seems it's a famous thing...

Farmers, botting, etc.. from the old review, also here, nothing changed uh :/

http://www.mmorpg.com/gamelist.cfm/setview/reviews/gameID/46/loadReview/38/page/1/from/

Comments ?
I've always been dissatisfied with the reviews of MMOs. Reviewers tend to look at a narrow picture for a broad constantly evolving entity. MMOs are so volatile that you could end up with a different score simply by switching servers.

That said most of the things they talk about are pretty accurate. The problem is that they fail to look at the whole picture.
Actually I think she's right on just about all points, even about the community. The only thing was her paragraph that came across like all boxed characters are bots.
I give her a 9.5
I think most of the review was pretty good, however I have two points I protest. First, I get incredibly angry when the farmers are all labeled as Chinese. I can't believe that the website let that go through.

The second was she says you have to grind in the same place all the time. That was true way back, but it is not true any longer. Especially at the higher level there are multiple spots to grind, so if you get tired of one, you can move on to the next.
You're still pretty limited because of the way drops work, so if you need certain drops and because of politics, hunting ground can be pretty limited. L2 is also incredibly timeconsuming in travel and gathering people, which leads to the assumption of staying in one place. But I do agree that her point about that was way too general.

And yeah, you're right, most farmers definetly aren't chinese anymore. :/
yeah, this review is pretty spot on, I am glad someone gave Lineage II an honest review.
I do disagree with the botting boxed characters. Hardly anyone does that. I MANUALLY box our SE. tyvm!

Yeah, I hope NCsoft reads this with shame, and maybe do something about this.
not to be racist, but more often then not, they are.

Research the poverty in the East, and you will understand why a human being will sit in front of a computer on a 12hr shift for 1.25/hour ruining your gaming experience.
My issue with it was the comment about role-playing. I've commented on the article, but there is a good rp community in the game.

http://www.l2rpa.org is just one of the hubs for that community.
Right, and even on Teon, there are plenty of RolePlayers !
I cant stress this enough : "yes you can RolePlay in Lineage II" !
(and i cant stress this enough also : "no you dont have to be a ****** to RolePlay, you can do it just for the fun of it" :p)
Anyway, about the review, it was kinda funny because when i read the part where they were criticizing the bots, chinese farmers, ebayers and so on, guess what was the ad displayed right next to the article on their website ?
Yes, it starts with an "I" and ends with an "E" :D

Anyway, about the review, it was kinda funny because when i read the part where they were criticizing the bots, chinese farmers, ebayers and so on, guess what was the ad displayed right next to the article on their website ?
Yes, it starts with an "I" and ends with an "E"


lol
kinda like the guy who complains about bots and then goes and ebays himself a new weapon

Right, and even on Teon, there are plenty of RolePlayers !



You'll notice I mentioned you guys too, Grazzt. And I'm still trying to touch base with you on Teon. I think I just keep missing you.
Yep, thanx for that ! :D
I'll be ingame this afternoon (2/3 PM GMT), and this evening (8/9 PM GMT), let's try to meet then ! :)
I found it was an very accurate review of the game.