SinEater Quest

Can someone give me an insight here?

I have been trying to turn in a sineater and the Black Judge isn't taking away any PKs. I've now leveled it one level above me... and it still isn't working. This is 3rd time I've tried to turn it in. It was 2 levels above me this last time, so I just leveled myself so now it is one level above me... and the black judge says my sins are taken a way, but they are still there. And if i click on the button that says "what do i do with my sins left" (or something like that) it says the sineater will disappear with everything in the inventory. I already tried that once, and it did disappear and I had to make another one.

Is there a secret? Something I'm missing???

doesn't sound like your doing anything wrong. I've never heard of someone getting 0 pks taken away but maybe its possible?

The sin eater must be put away means not summoned.

I have the sineater put away when I click on the judge. This isn't just one time 0 have been removed. This is the third time. Any other insight?

I dunno. I'm a summoner and can't do this quest without leaching from clannies.