why do we have a "suggestions forum"? i mean mistryl done a sticky in which it said "we will not be able to reply to all of the threads in this forum". But a better sentence is "we will never reply to any of the threads in this forum".
why do we do some suggestions (goods or bads) if we haven't any feed-back?
At least, NA NCSoft doesn't know communication rules? May i suggest to some ppl in NA NCSoft staff to go back to school to learn to communicate (Delete a thread like this one is not "communicate", it's a censure)?
Just because a thread in the Suggestions forum isn't replied to, it doesn't mean that the idea hasn't been passed along. We also do not post when a suggestion is sent to the dev team because it will only encourage players to ask "Why not this idea" or "Have you sent this one". (And likely "bump until we get a reply!" and so on.)
Game suggestions are appreciated and passed along on a regular basis.
And finally, unconstructive and hostile threads are typically removed from any forum on the message board.
that being the case, would it be at all possible for the reverse to be true? would any communique from devs onto this particular board (or game suggestions in general) be possible when additional information is required/a misunderstanding has occurred?
i don't say that you (NA NCS6ft staff) don't look at our suggestions, but i say that you never say "good idea", or "not be applied" or anything else. It's not coz you say "good idea" that it may in the game at next update/addon...
Feedback is really important for everybody : you need our feedback for suggestions, events, bots, ... and we need your feedback to know that we are heard. look : lots of us complain about petitions, login problems, bots... why? because you don't say anything.
none of our suggestions have ever been implemented
saying that one has just because it makes it in game and someone on these forums suggested it is kinda like saying cars have wheels because thats what you told the car company you wanted
none of our suggestions have ever been implemented
saying that one has just because it makes it in game and someone on these forums suggested it is kinda like saying cars have wheels because thats what you told the car company you wanted
indirectly, yes they were; pet buffaloes and cougars and kookaburras were an offshoot of an NA idea.
ever read the suggestions forum? full of "ungimp my dwarf in pvp" and "give me event with free adena for doing nothing" and "auction house/server/account xfer plzzzzzz "
good thing that the KR dev team doesnt take those suggestions seriously.
indirectly, yes they were; pet buffaloes and cougars and kookaburras were an offshoot of an NA idea.
not
my only korean source is hellrose who stated that the koreans wanted more soloability than we ever did
our suggestions are more about pvp while theirs are more about pve
so if the only thing you think was implemented because of us was actually suggested in korea what does that tell you?
so if the only thing you think was implemented because of us was actually suggested in korea what does that tell you?
Maybe it's because the idea, no matter whose it was originally, was well liked by the development team. I've seen this on the City of Heroes/City of Villains forum as well, where people don't see that their input is important to the Devs there, when in many cases ideas that were first suggested on the boards did make it into the game, though in a form that wasn't immediately recognizable as the forum suggestion. The biggest problem I see is that the Devs for Lineage 2 are in Seoul and post only on the Korean boards, as far as I can tell. I would love to see something like the Dev Digest on the City of Heroes board here, but that would require the devs to either post here, or have someone accurately translate their posts from the Korean boards.
Quote:
so if the only thing you think was implemented because of us was actually suggested in korea what does that tell you?
Maybe it's because the idea, no matter whose it was originally, was well liked by the development team. I've seen this on the City of Heroes/City of Villains forum as well, where people don't see that their input is important to the Devs there, when in many cases ideas that were first suggested on the boards did make it into the game, though in a form that wasn't immediately recognizable as the forum suggestion. The biggest problem I see is that the Devs for Lineage 2 are in Seoul and post only on the Korean boards, as far as I can tell. I would love to see something like the Dev Digest on the City of Heroes board here, but that would require the devs to either post here, or have someone accurately translate their posts from the Korean boards.
well the fact is we had something like that
in the "ask the devs thread" (or something similar) we asked what suggestions have we made that were implemented
the answer was the baby pets for soloing since koreans dont want to solo
the only korean source i know says koreans like to solo more than we do O.o
I was thinking about this thread and a suggestion that Maline made once about a "common suggestions" sticky, and I combined the two ideas. I answered a few common suggestions in this thread (http://boards.lineage2.com/showflat.php?Cat=0&Number=813314), and I'll update it with other frequently made suggestions in the future. While we can't reply to every idea, hopefully this gives a little bit of feedback for suggestions made in the forum.
none of our suggestions have ever been implemented
saying that one has just because it makes it in game and someone on these forums suggested it is kinda like saying cars have wheels because thats what you told the car company you wanted
When C5 got launched I suggested the "return to login when getting disconnected" (http://boards.lineage2.com/showflat.php?Cat=0&Board=suggestions&Number=676736 &Searchpage=3&Main=676736&Words=Istari_wizard&topi c=&Search=true#Post676736) feature and now we got it in interlude (it might have been suggested in Korea to)...anyway now I know that some of our suggestions are taken seriously.
When C5 got launched I suggested the "return to login when getting disconnected" feature and now we got it in interlude (it might have been suggested in Korea to)...anyway now I know that some of our suggestions are taken seriously.
When C5 got launched I suggested the "return to login when getting disconnected" feature and now we got it in interlude (it might have been suggested in Korea to)...anyway now I know that some of our suggestions are taken seriously.
and you think korea didnt suggest it first? O.o
Why do you think I included "it might have been suggested in Korea to" ?
I now suggest that they should just off-shoot from the Korean development team and continue with a seperate NA team... oh wait, the Korean market is about 100 times larger than NA... nevermind, we'll just give NA the leftovers.
I believe the original U.S Lineage team has been seperated at least in part from the Korean devs. If memory serves me correct they actually get some stuff that players ask for.
Korea and NA players are much different. I enjoy the game and all and don't want everything changed. There have just been some good suggestions on NA that could help OUR community and possibly make more player base.
Oh well. Unless Korea gives us NA people more freedom I don't think we will move much forward.