Lab Test 123 - Seraph Heavy Armor vs Eternal Heavy Armor (Tank)

~Request by metaxasz250~
Testing: Seraph/Eternal Heavy Armor on Tank
Question: Seraph heavy set +6/+8 Vs Eternal heavy set +6+8. i want to test the amount of dmg they receive from an r99 weapon especially dagger full buffed against 99 lvl tank with wiz harmony for each one of the 4 sets if possible
Reason: i want to check if the amount of adena and nscoins worths the trouble for eternal set. i think many ppl ask themselves the same so it ll be very helpfulCharacter A: Level 99 Dark Elf Othell Ghost Hunter
Character A Weapon: Amaranthine Shaper
Character A Armor: Eternal Leather Set
Character A Buffs: Melodies+Sonatas+Warrior Harmony
Skill: Backstab (lvl 8)
Character B: Level 99 Human Sigel Phoenix Knight
Character B Buffs: Melodies+Sonatas+Wizard Harmony (Player’s Request)

Seraph Heavy Set +0:
P. Def. Stat: 4,665
Damage on Tank: 2,111

Seraph Heavy Set +6:
P. Def. Stat: 5,049
Damage on Tank: 1,953

Seraph Heavy Set +8
P. Def. Stat: 5,564
Damage on Tank: 1,800
---------------------------------
Eternal Heavy Set +0:
P. Def. Stat: 4,840
Damage on Tank: 2,039

Eternal Heavy Set +6:
P. Def. Stat: 5,224
Damage on Tank: 1,891

Eternal Heavy Set +8
P. Def. Stat: 5,758
Damage on Tank: 1,744

so the only real damage reduction boost in a +8 R99 set lies if it is fully pvp'd

Comparisons

Maximum
Seraph Heavy Set +0 =>2111
Eternal Heavy Set +8 =>1744
17,3% damage reduction

Normal +6/+0
Seraph Heavy Set +6 =>1953
Eternal Heavy Set +0 =>2039
4,4% damage addition

Normal +6/+6
Seraph Heavy Set +6 =>1953
Eternal Heavy Set +6 =>1891
3,1% damage reduction = Obisidian lvl 2

Possible +8/+6
Seraph Heavy Set +8 =>1800
Eternal Heavy Set +6 =>1891
5% damage addition ;) Seraph ftw

Impossible +8/+8
Seraph Heavy Set +8 =>1800
Eternal Heavy Set +8 =>1744
3,1% damage reduction = Obisidian lvl 2

so the only real damage reduction boost in a +8 R99 set lies if it is fully pvp'd

Isn't it easier to get Seraph +8 and make it blessed than make Eternal ~pvp ?

Isn't it easier to get Seraph +8 and make it blessed than make Eternal ~pvp ?

Cheaper*)

could we take these notes for all the seraph vs. eternal sets in their tiers (light and robe, aswell)?

I'm thinking to stick with my seraph robe, or at least upgrade it to +6, if it proves being the same worthy than R99 ~ at least the stats are the same.