I would like to ask Juji for a test but i dont have the 15 posts since i am not active at the forum.
The test i want is to check 3 different weapons that tanks use in pvp. They could be tested with 99 SK (any specialization would do) using e.g. Last Judgement skill against any 99 toon in Eternal Armor with full atributes. The weapons i want ot test are:
1. C Grade sword-blunt (Health sa or so)
2. Forgotten Blade Health, 300 attri, PVP
3. Apocalypse Cutter Health+Haste, 300 attri
The point of the test is to check the damage done by each weapon so as to calculate if it is better to use a lower weapon with a top augment (eg passive reflect) or a higher grade weapon with a simple augment.
To be more specific, i currently own 3 weapons:
1. Yaksa Mace (c grade) Health with Passive Reflect
2. Forgotten Blade Health, Passive Clarity, 300 attri, PVP
3. Apo Cutter Health+Haste, simple augment, 300 attri
In Oly i use the first one against DD classes and the other 2 against other tanks mostly. The passive clarity comes pretty handy when i have to use more skills because of the duration of the fight, while passive reflect helps win matches with high damage output classes, when they are close to my lvl of course.
So, if anyone has an opinion or experience which weapon is best to use and against which classes, it would be very helpful.