About NC making money and p2w in gaming

General Discussion Started Last reply 17 posts
Well im all for NC to earn profit and keep publishing game but it seems they are doing it the wrong way. Game is not free to play, if you play it for free you are in huge disadvantage just take in consideration 20% cd on evas rune, its 20% damage boost, 20% heal boost.. 30k hp pots? talismans, epics, enchants its clearly p2win

Its not free and it never will be, but there is an old saying - greedy person plays twice, at least in Latvia we say so.

There is no such thing as free in this world of gaming, you pay one or another way and as a gamer the sooner you find out that it is more effective to get you but off the chair, get some job, play on evenings and weekends and invest some little % of you earnings in to the game or if you are hardcore invest alot + you have cash to spent on party, woman, cars, new pc, sniffing glue and fun stuff like that :D

pay to play is not a bad game model, p2win is

There are few games that can manage to be f2p and still earn alot of cash, League fo Legends for example, i have played it for 2 seasons, have bought some skins that give 0 benefit to my stats just cos they are rly rly awesome, and if you look how much players that game have and how much money they make you can tell that im not the only one who invests there.
Like this teemo skin, cost me 20eur https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=uK9qdIb6CFs
Like this sona skin with actual soundtrack its not just visuals it comes with that ingame music
https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=GGBDz927TZ4

Another example is Path of Exile, with its skins and inventory slots, they have took another approach to drop, good , rly good stuff drops there alot so instead of nerfing drop and making people to pay for little more chance of dropping something they went "*** it , let it rain legendary" and instead after some time your inventory becomes full of rly good gear you will want to try out on another class so you just buy another inventory slot

With this im saying you don't need to *** up game to the point when with no cashing in its becomes slow, boring and not rewarding. Cashing in will come if game will be fun but not the other way. All these types of exp runes just show how much game should be speed up to not be boring at least at 1-85.

Afc knowing NC it would be pointless to ask for subscription type and no cash shop, ofc not cos you are just too greedy and even if you would make subscription again there would be still cash shop and it would make it p2w +subscription :D :D :D its so bad that its even funny


What you could do is make some level restriction to f2p players, like 1-99, f2p, from 99+ you need subscription like prestige pack. That would bring you some steady income. Everyone who has a job, or who's family has a job can afford 20 euros in month for a game, if you someone cant afford that - then stop playing video games and get a job already lol. But there is a thing, for that subscription - game needs to be rewarding, with drops you care to get with exp that make you progress b4 you hit pension, with that feeling that you come home from work , you log in your game and you have a good time instead of constantly boiling inside your head" - wtf is this drop, why this raid im killing for 30 mins is giving me 0 exp, why all my adena goes to spiritshots and im still doing garbage damage, do i need to reroll? i have spent so much time and now my character is just a cannon meat in pvp? why is spoil such a garbage, why i wasted my time on spoiler to get 2% spoil chance wof something that is at least not garbage?"

I have heard this argument - well Asian people are more realistic, they understand that life is not fair and so they are ok with p2w. Im saying this cos many Asian games are grind fest p2w. Once again who has not seen this plz, greet perspective form how developers think http://www.gdcvault.com/play/1016417/-100-000-Whales-An Back to topic, so that s why NC korea makes Lineage 2 so slow and boring to have that realistic life_is_not fair feeling?

Rly? Is that why you play videogames to feel that realistic life_is_not _fair feeling? I dont thing that life is not fair and im sorry if you your country makes you feel that way. My job is not easy and i work alot still its ok, im good ty. Weird people they are if they are motivated by this i must say. Im playing games cos there are things i do not want to experience for real like taking siege to some castle, ya its awesome in game but i don't rly want to kill someone in real life, its probably in genes of every male to like fighting, conquering some land and stuff like that but that's just an emotion i love to experience in games, and im not playing to feel realistic in that way, i want to get cool stuff, kill epic monsters, siege castles and kill enemies who are somehow +- equal in skill and gear so no one can tell me ( you won just cos you pay or cos you have spent your last 10 years in this game) i want competitive and fair gameplay and thrilling battles but it will not happen if NC keeps this - life is not fair, deal with p2w , strategy. game will keep losing players until the point when even big whales who are cashing the most will find it boring when there is no one to kill and then poof, its gone.

Game needs to become pay 2 play or at least some content needs to be locked for f2p, like sieges, epics so NC gets income w/o selling op stuff, at least at some end game point with may be some exceptions like clan who gets Aden gets that prestige pack while it owns it. I wonder what sieges would be like then if something this cool would be the price. Instead of exploiting that group of gambling addicts who will spent thousands of dollars for the gamble events or enchanting scrolls to get you spikes of income you should go in direction of steady but long term income, where you don't have to nerf drop to make people buy drop rune, make garbage exp so people buy exp rune, make garbage enchant chance so people buy enchant stones - just make affordable subscription that will make everything rewarding and so most people can afford it. Sure let there be f2p but until some level, except some content like sieges, epics, some levels, i dont know yet its much to think of and there are many variations hwo this could be done w/o p2w.


Well that't what i think of p2w, f2p, p2p for now. I would like to hear what other people think and lets discuss this to one goal, make L2 great, not decent, not bearable but great. There is nothing, literally nothing impossible if when it comes to e game, that's why people play them, you cannot make world perfect but you can make game that makes you feel like you live in one.
I would like to hear what other people think and lets discuss this to one goal, make L2 great, not decent, not bearable but great.



i newer saw ppl that change something while its going good, so why ncsoft must do ?
they got profit, ppl play/pay that, all fine for them

you dont want to pay and want to compete.. just play LoL or start use your brain/hands/your time and learn how to get all that you need.
i newer saw ppl that change something while its going good, so why ncsoft must do ?
they got profit, ppl play/pay that, all fine for them

you dont want to pay and want to compete.. just play LoL or start use your brain/hands/your time and learn how to get all that you need.

well i do play LoL also and i do invest there way more than i will invest in Lineage 2 cos here its not worth it, I did buy prestige here but i will be cancelling that for next month, its garbage at least until lvl 99+ where pvp starts, and time is only thing that i don't have, i can play daily, active +- 2 hours, its ok for dailies and the rest time im just fishing, and im not the losing side here, NC and other casual players are, you are not paying i guess you have your brains :D i am not paying cos i feel its not worth it, so they have to make p2w shop to survive
Tl dr dc

You know what.. go play LoL...
If you want to win invest...
Every game which mmorpg based is p2w.. look on wow, blade and soul, tera...

If you cant accept it that game is p2win then my advice is bsoe here in forum and go play on your cave...

P.s. i play dota 2 alot but i play l2 more coz i love it.. i invest time and money so i get what i want.. same like shopping.. game is business.. take it or leave it..:mad::mad::mad:
game is a business i 100% agree on that, but as with lol, poe, dota, starcraft example, game can get lots of cash and still not be p2w

one thing that makes lol, dota, starcraft, cs so popular is world tournaments, it drags huge player pool and keeps community active, when game is p2w there will be no such thing, i would not be surprised if LoL earns more money from hardware advertisements than NC earns in L2 nc coin selling, you can do business in many ways.

You rly want this game to die? After black desert, blade and soul, albion online, bless online, eq next how many new gamers will be attracted to this kind of business +old game with most of its content empty and useless? Only way for l2 to become relevant is to become fair, balanced, with no p2w elements , start to do may be live castle sieges with professional commentators, become viral, visible may be worlds olympiad championship with 1v1 , 3v3 7v7 battles and so on
even if that would be hard at start NC has a pool of income form gw2 and lineage 1 but for lineage 2 interest is fading, there are mostly old players playing not new ones
https://www.google.com/trends/explore#q=%2Fm%2F04tdsp%2C%20%2Fm%2F04gmskf%2C%20% 2Fm%2F0y66zll%2C%20%2Fm%2F04n3w2r%2C%20%2Fm%2F02q2 5c_&cmpt=q&tz=Etc%2FGMT-2
one thing that makes lol, dota, starcraft, cs so popular

Is that there is no persistence. You join, you are on equal footing. Nobody has hoarded billions of $ so that even you insta-kill a person every single time/round, it does not come back after you with 5 divine rapiers/superbuffs/a large amount of units produced even before you installed the game/AWP + all armor/grenade pack EVERY. SINGLE. TIME.

BDO will be successfully destroyed before it can reach EU/NA. I have my sources on this. BnS is just terribad, and even at endgame that doesn't change.

Live CS or PvP is only done in Korea. NCW has no crew for this, and there is literally no audience. Despite the fact that all the tools are there. You would only need a commentator and you can broadcast away.


L2 was always designed the way that gear is hard to obtain and it contributes very much to a player character's capabilities. Perhaps it is time you acknowledged it? It's not going away, it's the essence of L2.
Is that there is no persistence. You join, you are on equal footing. Nobody has hoarded billions of $ so that even you insta-kill a person every single time/round, it does not come back after you with 5 divine rapiers/superbuffs/a large amount of units produced even before you installed the game/AWP + all armor/grenade pack EVERY. SINGLE. TIME.

BDO will be successfully destroyed before it can reach EU/NA. I have my sources on this. BnS is just terribad, and even at endgame that doesn't change.

Live CS or PvP is only done in Korea. NCW has no crew for this, and there is literally no audience. Despite the fact that all the tools are there. You would only need a commentator and you can broadcast away.


L2 was always designed the way that gear is hard to obtain and it contributes very much to a player character's capabilities. Perhaps it is time you acknowledged it? It's not going away, it's the essence of L2.

well do you think that game in a state that it is now is ok,and will keep players?
I think because of latest game designs such as dota 2 and lol make a player base role play and kinda stuff that lineage 2 offers destroy the game... imagine in dota 2 you create char in less an hour your godly and after a game you make another 1... lineage 2 game design is like you make a story out of your char... and generation this days are lazy... so lazy... dont want hard work and get their hands dirty.. dont want to toil nor to plow.. and im guessing your 1 of them.. if not.. and if you like this game prove it and devote to the game some time and spare money you got.. if not play casual and free but dont complain for what you get playing casual and free...:D:D:rolleyes:
And btw use your brain a little.. do some reading how its done and how it works.. not only this forum offers info on game mechanics.. i found another site from eu i think has great info in game... read... same like life... learn learn learn..

And ill share you a secret.. in life to be successful dont share what you learned to others.. keep it to yourself until yiu make/made a profit out of it..
And ill share you a secret.. in life to be successful dont share what you learned to others.. keep it to yourself until yiu make/made a profit out of it..

That used to work back in the day, now it's about who will **** everyone up first by sharing info that destroys all abilities to make profit.
I have been playing lineage 2 since C1 and back then you had to pay $15 a month to play and on top of that the "top players" were the botters and people who bought adena/characters from farmers. Nowadays, you don't have to bot to be a top player, you can just buy your way in through a legitimate source that won't get you banned.

I came back to the game for the first time since f2p about 10 months ago. I see people complaining about how only people who pay can get these good items, and I can tell you that it's a lie. I have my characters logged in 24/7 with buy and sell shops and I have been slowly but surely gearing myself very well. Adena is easy to be made if you know how to play the market. Obviously ncoin buyers have it easier, but it doesn't mean a f2p person cannot enjoy the game and have fun.

The game has ALWAYS been p2w, the only difference is now ncsoft is getting it's cut.

PS: Micro payments are the new form of income for video games, L2 is not the first, the only, or the last to implement this. If you don't like p2w, don't play video games.
the nc shop is ridiculous, "events" are just a joke, they could simply make p2p with 1month trial with an item u can buy as player and sell it ingame to extend time, same as eve online. So the players that play longer wouldnt have advantage of 1000% more dmg just because he was here for the "event" of the unobtainable items. But thats never hapening because here at ncwest game management logic does not exist. They recently even made divine elixir recipe unobtainable so u would need to buy roses every time on new server. The glory days of l2 is long gone, now there is just handfull of people like 100 per server playing rather then 2-3k before the p2w model
Everyone that has stated "Get over it" "L2 has always been like this" etc etc etc

Lineage 2 has been difficult to obtain END GAME GEAR but gear was OBTAINABLE. Dark gear? Good luck. Bloody gear? Good luck. End game raids? Can't farm open field since they are 24/7 bot farmed. Dragons? Farmed by the same clans barely drops anything, leaders get dragon claw. (yay 1 claw only 9 more to go!).
Now though, it's 100% PAY TO WIN. You want adena, buy it using ncoin, you want to gain more than 1% a day, buy ncoin. You want drop, buy ncoin.

It's a business? You can do a business without the need to screw your customer base. They continuously to tell us to screw off (by not doing anything and ignoring) and yet people like some in this thread just keep spending.

Look at GW2, they make more money than L2 in the west, but yet that game isn't P2W. Why? Oh right, b/c they actually listen. Look at what they did to someone that EXPLOITED and CHEATED. If you haven't seen it, then google it. Pretty much they destroyed his gear and killed his toon then deleted it.

Enough is enough.
yea exactly that's the attitude, feels like saying in redneck bar that there is a dirt in the glass that judging by appearance is starting to grow a colony but all you get in response is - well that dirt was there already when i started to work here in C1, you folks want everything easy now, clean, it seems you have spent too much time in these fancy private bars! you know what http://www.t-shock.eu/nahled/KUyJ7xkf.jpg
OP: Is the issue NCSoft or you?

Do they do all those things? Yes
Will that change? No

If "You" have not learned by now that is their business model and Ethics then the issue is you. You have the option to spend your time with several gaming companies and you chose Ncsoft.

Perhaps the problem is you.
OP: Is the issue NCSoft or you?

Do they do all those things? Yes
Will that change? No

If "You" have not learned by now that is their business model and Ethics then the issue is you. You have the option to spend your time with several gaming companies and you chose Ncsoft.

Perhaps the problem is you.

well too bad i have no other option, i would play L2 on euro server but euro server is plain Russian, most people will not even answer you'r pm if you don't write in ru, so until i want to be a part of this game and its community i have no other options than to play here and therefor i have no other option how to give constant feedback on my game experience and encourage others to do the same cos its the only way to make one my favorite open world pvp/pk games live again. Also too bad im not rich, i would just buy publishing rights in eu just for lineage 2
i newer saw ppl that change something while its going good, so why ncsoft must do ?
they got profit, ppl play/pay that, all fine for them

you dont want to pay and want to compete.. just play LoL or start use your brain/hands/your time and learn how to get all that you need.

wrong bat, people change things, not at once but thy do, example my post form another acc long ago

http://boards.lineage2.com/showthread.php?t=226844

asked for more daily and faster exp, date 12-29-2011, 06:18 PM

got this in reply
Do you know what game your playing... haha this will never happen... you might as well just quit now and stop wasting your time then...

Underground patch - +clan exp buff, +exp runes in level up rewards, +exp in katria

They are slowly getting that this game is too slow and changing it, slowly or not but its happening, just don't start with attitude - nothing will ever change!! There is old saying in Latvian - :"Kas neprasa - tas nedabūn" (The one who never asks - never gets)